Ps. My thoughts are a little disorganised, so if there’s anything problematic or inaccurate, just let me know.
Let’s begin by talking about the hooked cross. Most of the culture around the world see it in a positive light. In India, they call it swastika, in China wan or wanzi, in Japan manji, in Korea manja, and so on. There are also various native American groups as well as Europeans (Ukraine, Finland) who revere this symbol. And from little that I know, I also heard about it being part of Jewish synagogues in some places.
Despite these groups being cooperative and making heavy changes to the symbols, by rejecting the angled cross, and adding dots and curves, the hate against PoC for following their beliefs did not stop. Could you deny the bigots a symbol for their evil ideology, by letting PoC reclaim the symbol? Yes. But would they choose to? No. For about 3000 years, it was a revered symbol in most parts of the world. For almost a quarter of a century, it was a hate symbol in a small part of the world. And yet, here we are.
Putting aside the symbol, let’s talk about the word itself. For most of the Indians out there, having the word “swastika” appropriated by Nazi is horrible - it robbed the original meaning of the word स्वस्तिक. People out there name their kids Swastik (masculine) and Swastika (feminine). I can’t just imagine how they’ll be bullied. Swastika is also related to various figures in the Hindu mythology. There’s also a yoga pose called the Swastik asana. There’s also Buddhist references out there that I’m unaware of.
If there’s so much concern about this hooked cross being a hate symbol, why isn’t it being calling it flyfot or hakenkreuz? Surely, those are Euro-centric words, right? Why drag a culture that had nothing to do with the Holocaust?
Enough about the swastika. Let’s talk about an imperialist symbol that is still respected. The symbol of terror, bloodshed, capitalism and colonialism. The Union Jack.
The first Union Jack was made in the early 1600s, when England and Scotland unified. In the 1800s, they colonized Ireland, and thus formed the modern Union Jack that you all know today.
Under this symbol and every version of it that has existed, 165 million Indians were killed in just forty year’s time - colonialism lasted for almost 200 years, starting from 1757 to 1947, and also add the other victims of colonialism of the British Empire, from America, Africa, Australia and Asia, as well as Europe. We are talking about atrocities like artificial famines, starvation, pogroms, slave-trade, and apartheid, just to name a few. National and religious artifacts were desecrated and stolen. Territories were robbed of their wealth. Natural resources destroyed. Artisans and craftsmen, torch bearers of culture were killed, or handicapped. Let’s also not forget the aftermath of disastrous independence of colonies. Like for example, the Partition of undivided India.
And yet, this hate symbol exists out there. People wave this flag in pride. The vilification of swastika was never about the Nazis. It is a convenient excuse to deflect how the Allied forces and anyone associated with it are the good guys at the expense of making vulnerable groups feeling uncomfortable. Invasion of Vietnam? War crime sponsored in Gaza? Genocide in Bangladesh? “We defeated the Nazis, we can’t be that evil”.
If you’re Indian, get used to being the most hated race on the planet. If you live in the west, get a gun. Consider lying about your ethnicity when specifically asked (people are dumb and any Indian person can pass as Arab, Latino, Afro-Latino, etc to them)
Whites are obsessed with the word ‘swastika’ because they lived in swamp holes when the rest of the world was civilized. Also the same reason they’re obsessed with ‘aryan’ (originally used to describe Northwest Indians) and why they’ve successfully retconned it into meaning blue haired and blonde eyed
“For about 3000 years, it was a revered symbol in most parts of the world. For almost a quarter of a century, it was a hate symbol in a small part of the world.” This is also true of literally every single plant and animal with an entry on Wikipedia. They all had various indigenous names for 3000+ years, and are now called “Splotchson’s Babcock” because a guy named Splotchson was rich enough to tour Sumatra 90 years ago
This is something only a Non-White person from a Non-Western country could write lol. Those aforementioned Europeans are called nazis.
They like to create false history about how the Swastika was the symbol of the Aryans (even though it was found in the Indus Valley centuries before the Aryans even existed, not to mention in pre-Columbian Apache pottery, meaning that it has extremely non-Central Asian roots, let alone European)