Title says it all, i want to lose weight and also build some muscle, ive have been hitting the gym and cutting my calories by 500-900cal for the past two months, while i am seeing some muscle growth, its not very substantial or something people around me will notice, ive also lost about 2kgs which is not much so i am thinking of doing a 200cal surplus for a month to see how it goes I wanted to get some advice as well as read other people’s experiences

  • ccunix@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 year ago

    To grow muscle you need fuel. There is a reason Brian Shaw eats 10+k calories a day.

    If you want to lose fat you need to burn calories faster than you eat them.

    That is why people looking to “get shredded” will run a bulk then cut cycle. Eat and train like a madman to build them muscle, then go into a caloric deficit (eat less than you burn) and train as hard a your body will let you.

    • DFTBA_FTW@lemmy.fmhy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 year ago

      Brian Shaw is also 6’8" and 400lbs of muscle and he didnt get there by eating 10k calories a day, he stays there by eating 10k calories.

      Muscle is metobolcially active, about 20cals a day, so if (subtracting bone, organs, etc) he’s 280lbs of muscle, 5,600 calories is literally just to keep is muscle from melting away.

      He also exercises as a job, probably close to 2k cals a day.

      You need about 1200kcal a day for metabolic function.

      So he’s burning ~ 8k calories a day, the 10k calories is also when he’s bulking up so he’s trying to put on size both fat and muscle tissure that already exists (it can take years to build 20lbs of muscle, but lose it and try and put it back on and you can do it in months).

      Tldr: You do not need to eat absurd amounts of calories to out on muscle, just aim for ~200 calories a day more than your maintenance. Eating 5k calories a day when you are 5’9" and 170lbs at 20% body fat will not magically make you put on lbs and lbs of muscle a month.

      • ccunix@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        My point was that you need to be in a surplus to build muscle.

        I agree, you do not need to be in an 8k calorie surplus to build muscle. That is excessive, but that is why he the most successful currently active strongman and we are not.