carpoftruth [any, any]

  • 12 Posts
  • 516 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 23rd, 2023

help-circle


  • I find it helpful to distinguish between the ukrainian state under the zelensky regime, other state-like forces in ukraine like their fascist militia, the ukrainian citizenry broadly, and the people of eastern ukraine/donbass/Crimea. If you just lump all of those groups together as “ukraine” it is harder to have a coherent analysis of the situation because each of those groups have distinct interests and incentives. I’ve gotten libs to engage with those distinctions before by talking about different levels of government/regions of my own country, highlighting places where the federal government does things that don’t align with my interests.

    The concept of indivisible security is useful to discuss in the context of nato/US v Russian relations as well. Again, this relates to incentives of the different parties.

    All this to say, I have a lot of sympathy for the ukrainian populace at large, especially those in the east most directly affected by the war. I have less sympathy for the formal ukrainian state and their roll of the dice/being led down the garden path by the US, and I have no sympathy for fascists.




















  • This isn’t a dam breaking. The pod jons don’t have power. They and their simpering fans will vote for biden regardless, even if they are biting their tongues while they do it.

    Several years ago, the state preferred to see police stations burned and millions of people in the streets and disappeared BLM organizers before making any concessions to the cause of “black people don’t want to be extra judicially executed.” when pro-palestine protestors start being murdered by the police in the US, then that is a sign that the machine is at least being threatened, even if it isn’t a sign of breaking. We are not there.

    American foreign policy is not influenced by the electorate in any meaningful way. Even if it was, the American electorate does not vote based on foreign policy issues. Full stop.

    Like what’s the worst consequence here for pro Israel forces in the US? Biden loses? Who fucking cares, trump is 99% as much of a nazi on this topic, he just uses different rhetoric. He will not make any meaningful changes.